The conventional wisdom (now) is that the root relationship between Iberian and Continental Bell Beakers is merely a cultural one, and not much more. That's retarded, but ok, we'll start addressing this now.
This young wife, labeled I6475, tells us part of her people's story. She has no appreciable steppe ancestry and, looking at her mtdna (U5b3), we can comfortably presume that her maternal stock is native to the Spanish interior where it enjoyed a relatively high frequency since the Middle Neolithic (Szecsenyi-Nagy et al, 2017).
La Heredera de Henares, I6475, 4463 in the dig |
So far it seems that the heterogeneous Beakers within the Madrid/Castile watershed generally do have steppe ancestry, and about the amount you expect for the offspring in the initial stages of admixture. Most likely, this young lady represents one of the many mixed marriages between Beaker men and local women, and fully recognized and honored marriage, not just a woman being ravaged while thatch-roofed huts burn in the background.
She is clearly a full member of the Beaker society and her fine grave goods testify to this. She appears to have either been sprinkled with cinnabar and ochre (more likely a red dress or blanket) and she had a v-perforated button of African ivory. She holds a hardened copper awl in her left hand, and interestingly, a boar's tusk near her neck. It also took some effort to dig this grave. And more to the point, the presence of the copper awl in her left hand signifies her idealized status as the lady of a home (perhaps 'matron' if she had lived past her teenage years).
If you look at her head shape I think it would be fair to assume that she did not have a Beaker babyhood but was instead integrated into this local community by marriage (similar situation to I2787 SzigetszentmiklĂłs). Or was it the other way around? Maybe it was her husband who benefitted most from what she brought to this union - ranchland along the river?
Although she was only buried with a cooking pot, some of the other cemetery ceramics are typical of the Ciempozuelos style and tradition (Heras, Cubas and Bastida, 2012)
Above you can see just how different this girl (I6475 highlighted) compares to the man with the baby in the burial mound (I6471). That guy is at the high end of steppe spectrum, so high the Olalde authors had to break out Alcala de Henares into MAD1 and MAD2 groups.
(Barroso et al, 2018 http://dx.doi.org/10.5209/CMPL.62583) |
"Presence of steppe ancestry in five individuals from Camino de las Yeseras, LaMagdalena and Humanejos (Madrid, Spain)"
"Similar to the previous case, we show in Table S2 f4-statistics of the form f4(Mbuti,Test; BK_Spain_MAD1, BK_Spain_MAD2) and f4(Mbuti, Test; BK_Spain_MAD1,BK_Spain_Mag1). These statistics support the presence of Steppe-related ancestry inBK_Spain_MAD2 (individuals I6472, I6623, I6539 and I6588) and BK_Spain_Mag1(individual I6471), in contrast to the remaining 7 individuals from Madrid region(BK_Spain_MAD1) who lack this genetic signal. Sample I6471 is assigned a different label as it appears to have significantly more Steppe-related ancestry than theBK_Spain_MAD2 group (Figure S2a)..."
This matters because the truly diagnostic, bona fide Bell Beaker graves in the heart of Iberia, are all heterogenous steppic communities with native women and foreign men. I6475 is a snapshot of this process. Bros are in the next post.
"The archaeological site of La Magdalena is located on the youngest terrace of River Henares, on the right margin, northeast from the city of Alcalá de Henares (Madrid). This site is traversed by at least four paleochannels that lead into the previously mentioned river.
The artificial cave 4463 is the best preserved one. It is a single inhumation (I6475) of a young woman between 16 and 20 years old. She was buried with a V-perforated button made from African ivory and a suid canine next to her neck. Near her head, a non- decorated vessel and an arsenical copper awl in her left hand, were found. She was sprinkled with red ochre containing cinnabar."
The site was straight back, riparian zone of Henares in the background |
Rio Henares (Raimundo Pastor, commons) |
*Mesetan is used liberally to include the topographical mesetas, but also the Extramadura and the badlands suitable for ranching within the Spanish interior. Most anywhere the expansive Ciempozuelos group lands, with the assumption that they represent a tribe or confederation of some sort, to be distinguished from other peoples.
All the sites on the map are Beaker sites where some samples had Steppe admixture?
ReplyDeleteNo, actually it had to do with something else. Some of these sites are indeed sampled, and I'll be looking closer at the new samples in Olalde, 2019 which probably includes more of those. Really it was just to show how steppe ancestry is located in three sites around Madrid, Camino de Yeseras, Humanejos and Alcala de Heras.
DeleteI think you're right that R1b p312+ settled in Iberia during the Bell Beaker period not a later period. This is a minor but key detail which the DNA papers were wrong about. I noticed that the Iberian Beakers with Steppe admix had burial arrangement/goods typical of northern Beakers while Iberian Beakers without Steppe admix did not.
ReplyDeleteMy literal and figurative contention in "Marauder Mestans Take Booty",is that the center of gravity of the Beaker phenomenon in Iberia is in the hillbilly, cattle-focused interior where the strings were pulled, so to speak.
DeleteThe civilizations in Portual, Andalusia and Millares are similar to Haittian civilization in that there is elite dominance, and at least initially, will lag in y-chromosome replacement. But, we know this eventually happens.
cool Post
ReplyDeleteWhilst tongue- in-cheek; the idea of these backward hill-Billy’s isn’t true- as their copper technology, incl weapons; were more developed than the south
The mixing in central Iberia was selective- we don’t see native males with Central European males together; much like elsewhere in the BB areas (apart from Hungary perhaps) . It wasn’t a warm, fuzzy pan-mixia
Lastly; there is no elite dominance in Millares & other southern cultures- these are purely “native” phenomena; which then end as BB encroaches . The result isn’t a creole culture; but a new one- El Argar . Gradual outbreeding does not explain the biology nor cultural result of what occurred
Rob
Thanks, Maybe elite dominance is so far unsupported, but it could also be that Beakers are an independent component within these civilizations. Or it could be these cultures were swimming in the Beaker world system and some acculturation was inevitable.
DeleteMy understanding was that Los Millares was a pre-Beaker culture. Only toward the late phase do some BB huts and burials with BB items start appearing around it. As you have said previously, this seems to have often been accompanied by a hail of arrows. So, I suspect during the golden days of Millares, it was all local Iberian genetics. Thus, for ex, that 'Prince & his 20 wives ' buried in the tholoi- if he truly dates to 28/2700 BC, might be G2a or I2a. (?) Hopefully we might find out ..
DeleteRob
Totally agree. I bet he's already in the queue. Hopefully they do the women as well.
DeleteBtw; sorry for double post in wrong thread
ReplyDeleteRob
What is the dating of I6475? Assuming this is the cultural source of Bell Beaker at close to its origins, the bros should be our best clue to their details steppe origins.
ReplyDeleteNone of these are that old, at least this site and the ones nearby.
DeleteBy steppic I mean the ancestry component.
Delete